Historic Photo: Atlanta after Sherman’s March to the Sea, 1864.

atlanta after 1864 pd

This photo looks almost like one of the 19th century ghost towns of the Old West. It isn’t. This is Atlanta, one of the great cities of the South–or what was left of it–after the devastating military campaign in late 1864 by Union General William Tecumseh Sherman known as the “March to the Sea.” Having captured Atlanta in September, in the late fall Sherman proposed to Union commanders and to President Abraham Lincoln a new operation aimed at breaking the will and the ability of the Southern people to continue fighting the Civil War. By marching his armies from Atlanta, in the interior of Georgia, to Savannah on the coast, and tearing up all usable infrastructure along the way, Sherman intended to eliminate the last vestiges of support for the Southern war effort.

Sherman and his army set out on November 15, 1864. Carving a path of destruction through Georgia, the Union Army fought several battles along the way, including one at Waynesboro, Georgia on December 4th, 161 years ago today. The Union, being much more well-equipped and disciplined, completed their march and Sherman famously telegraphed Lincoln on December 21: “I beg to present you as a Christmas gift the city of Savannah.”

This photo shows the aftermath of Sherman’s work. Some buildings are in ruins (though I notice the saloon is completely intact), and the railroad tracks look like they need some work–Atlanta’s strategic significance was as a rail junction, and destruction of rail lines was one of Sherman’s major objectives. Yet curiously life is still going on here. At the left of the photo you see some people and carts coming and going, looking ghostly because they moved during the long shutter exposure. At the end of the street toward the left you can see mounds of dirt and piles of lumber as if rebuilding is going on, or about to begin. I also love the gloomy clouds above this scene. It’s rare to see weather depicted explicitly in these 19th century photos (though it does sometimes happen).

Southerners generally regard Sherman’s March to the Sea as a war crime, and perhaps it was. Unfortunately it has a lot of company–the sack of Jerusalem in the Crusades or the torpedoing of the Lusitania in World War I are other examples I’ve profiled here. But it was Sherman who reminded us, after the March was over, “War is all hell.” War is an atrocity by its very nature. That’s something I’ve learned quite vividly of late, regardless of which war you’re talking about or what moral arguments are used to justify it.

This photo, which is by 19th century photographer George N. Barnard, is in the public domain.
Advertisements

3 Comments

  1. Unfortunately it was largely 19th c. southerners who wrote the history of the American Civil War and depicted Sherman as a monster for burning down their ability to prolong the treasonous war that Georgia had started. Sherman was right. Military Science 101 teaches that the end of operations is to destroy the enemy’s ability to resist which is done by defeating his army in the field. Note the words are destroy and defeat, not necessarily kill. Far better to destroy his means of waging war as Sherman did than simply kill at lot of people. Body counts have never helped to win a war against a people defending their own land. Witness the Americans Revolution and the Indochina / Vietnam war. Likewise in WW II the allies crippled Germany’s rail infrastructure and isolated Japanese troops in Manchuria destroying the enemy’s ability to resist.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s